Ventura County bankruptcy filings jumped 59 percent in 2009 from the previous year, according to the U.S. Bankruptcy Court in Los Angeles.
It is a sign of the recession's toll, and even more drastic when compared to the peak of the housing boom in 2006 to 2009 -- a 606 percent increase in filings, from 583 to 4,117.
Nationwide, filings for fiscal year 2009 totaled 1.4 million, up 34.5 percent from the previous year, according to the Administrative Office of the U.S. Courts.
Ventura County falls within the Central District of California, a seven-county region that reported all bankruptcy filings rose 71 percent, from 57,145 in 2008 to 97,473 in 2009. Personal bankruptcies were not broken into a separate category by the bankruptcy court.
Local and national data also reveal a dramatic rise in the number of Chapter 11 filings, which allows businesses to operate as usual under court supervision until a reorganization plan is approved by two-thirds of the creditors.
In Ventura County, Chapter 11 filings have increased from three in 2006 to 30 in 2009. Among the local businesses that filed a Chapter 11 bankruptcy last year was the law firm Masry & Vititoe in Westlake Village -- made famous in the 2000 movie "Erin Brockovich." Nationwide, Chapter 11 filings rose from 8,799 in 2008 to 14,745 in 2009. Among the companies that filed for Chapter 11 protection last year were Reader's Digest Association Inc.; General Motors Corp.; Eddie Bauer Holdings Inc.; Chrysler LLC; Citadel Broadcasting Corp.; and the Tribune Co., publisher of the Los Angeles Times and Chicago Tribune.
What's different about some of these large Chapter 11 bankruptcies today is they aren't going through traditional reorganizations because bank money isn't there like it once was for restructuring, said Jack Williams, resident scholar at the Alexandria, Va.-based American Bankruptcy Institute.
"Most management wants to try the traditional route because it keeps the business on track, the employer in business, the tax base and keeps relationships in place," he said. "But now, because banks aren't doing financing with bankruptcies, (debtors) are looking to private markets, hedge funds, private equity funds and vulture capitalists."
A "vulture capitalist" buys new entities created by distressed companies. The crippled companies separate bad assets from good ones, with the good assets going to the new entities, Williams said, effectively allowing outside investors to cherry-pick and leave behind debts.
"So you're not seeing traditional reorganization," he said. The buyer instead comes in as the new entity's owner and "its carcass is picked clean of anything of value," he said.
Going forward, Williams forecasts a 20 percent to 25 percent increase in business bankruptcy filings this year.
As for consumer filings, he expects a slight but not significant rise. After the lengthy economic downturn, Williams is hearing from more and more people who've exhausted their savings. But for many of them filing for bankruptcy -- especially in the wake of the heightened fees imposed by the 2005 amendments to bankruptcy laws -- isn't an option.
"Now there are people who are way too poor to file a bankruptcy petition," he said.
Valencia attorney Louis Esbin, former president of the Central District Consumer Bankruptcy Attorneys Association, said membership in the group is on the rise. But the association is seeing more attorneys who have never practiced bankruptcy law.
"We call them newbies," Esbin said. "They're lawyers who've never practiced in this area before and they're advertising and soliciting business in this area, and they're having clients retain them."
The trend is raising concern among veteran bankruptcy lawyers and judges who fear people or businesses struggling with debt won't get quality representation, Esbin said. To address the issue, the association is setting up a mentoring program to help lawyers new to the practice. Esbin also is working with the Bankruptcy Law Advisory Commission to the State Bar of California to encourage more lawyers get certified. The certification means an attorney has met rigorous, objective standards and demonstrated knowledge in bankruptcy and/or creditors' rights law.
"That's one way the public can differentiate expertise," he said